Login   Sign Up 



 

A Book Leapt Off the Library Shelf

by di2 

Posted: 03 November 2005
Word Count: 528
Summary: An idiosycratic method for book selection.


Font Size
 


Printable Version
Print Double spaced


"The Unlikely Voyage of Jack de Crow", by AJ (Sandy) Mackinnon, practically leapt off the shelf into my hands. It was during one of my regular visits to the local library. There it was, in the travel genre section.

I skimmed the first page of the first chapter, as is my habit when choosing a book. Three amusing sentences bounced off the page.

The first sentence that got me, is as follows, "It was in many ways purely an accident that it happened at all."

The next was, "I have many heroes mostly drawn from the world of children's literature . . . the White Queen who made it her daily habit to believe six impossible things before breakfast . . . Dr Dolittle who sailed away in a ship with his monkey and his parrot, his pig and his duck, and bumped into Africa."

Hmmm, this looks good. So far the book measured up, so a quick read of the blurb at the back of the book. It still held my interest. Into my "book bag" it went.

Once home, I gave the book my serious focus. I had potentially four books to read plus others that were lying around in various places, not quite finished. So now Sandy's book had to pass a more rigorous test as it had lots of competition for my valuable reading time.

The ambience of a book is very important to me. The cover, the paper, the font and the text layout all assist, psychologically, to lead me into the book. The ambience of the book did not measure up. The text was small and close to the edges of the page. The layout of the page was not pleasing to the eye. Chapter headings were underlined similar to a typed draft of an essay. The paper was your usual paperback quality, poor. The cover was practical more than imaginative. However the photograph did help me get an idea of the size, colour and shape of Sandy (AJ) Mackinnon's boat.

Using my psychological idiosyncratic method for choosing a book I decided that there were more positive than negative points so I again read the Foreword by David Du Croz, Sandy Mackinnon's former boss and headmaster at Ellesmere College. Interesting. Another ambient barrier loomed, the paragraphs in the Foreword were too long making comprehension difficult, particularly when my eyes are sore, the television is invading my mind and dinner is on the table. But I persisted. Something was telling me I would be rewarded if I tried a little harder to access the book. Tenacity wins out every time.

David Du Croz's description of Sandy Mackinnon, in the Foreword, included the fact that Sandy had an "imaginative originality . . . which leads to the unexpected and makes things happen differently. He described him as a philosopher, a poet, an artist and a dramatist with creative urges along with a free spirit. This told me the book would be a good read. I haven't been disappointed.

Not many books make me laugh out loud but I had two real belly laughs before I was through the first chapter.

Read it, it's good.






Favourite this work Favourite This Author


Comments by other Members



Beadle at 14:14 on 04 November 2005  Report this post
A very different kind of book review. I would never consciously pick a book based on the quality of its paper - yes, cover design does have an impact - but I have to admit to being snotty about how the type is set. I think it comes from having a background in newspapers and design.

It's hard to know what to say about this. I did enjoy it to start with, the light, conversational tone, but half way through I got tired because I could not see the point. And it was only 500 words.

It was confusing as well, as you describe your reasons for picking the book off the library shelf in the first place, then seem to reject that decision making process for a new set of trials when you sit down to read it.

I know that you read the forward a couple of times, and that the author's headteacher thinks he's a good writer, and that you are enjoying the book, but I know nothing about the book itself.

Having said that, I do think you have an interesting style which, if you could discipline it a bit more, could make for an interesting and enjoyable read. I felt that I had entered into your world, which felt a little chaotic, but I was soothed by tea and buns, so it wasn't a bad place to be.

I'd say think about what you are trying to say a little more. What you want your reader to feel from your words.

Unfortunately I don't think I would rely on your book reviews when choosing my next book however.

di2 at 05:03 on 06 November 2005  Report this post
Thank you Beadle for taking the time to comment on my article. You are quite right when you suggest I should think about what I'm trying to say and what I want from the reader. I'm very new to writing and I haven't connected with the fact that I'm writing for an audience, the reader. It's true though. Part of the delight of writing something is having someone else enjoy it as much as you have enjoyed crafting it.

In the short time I have been a member of WriteWords it has had quite an impact on me. I'm sure it's because there is such good constructive feed back. And as a reader, I'm enjoying the writing and the interactive comments of others.

Thanks again.

Regards, Di2

di2 at 20:57 on 06 November 2005  Report this post
Beadle, I've given some thought about the fact that I haven't included, in this piece, information about the book. So I've added a bit of information as a comment. I will weave it into the piece in a little while.

This information is from the blurb on the book:

" 'Jack de Crow' is an epic voyage, undertaken with courage and recounted with flair and humour"

"A couple of quiet weeks' sailing on the river Severn was the intention. Somehow things got out of hand" writes A J Mackinnon. "A year later I had reached Romania and was still going."
Equipped with his cheerful optimism and a pith helmet, this Odysseus in a dinghy takes you with him from the borders of north Wales, to the Black Sea - 4900 kilometres over salt and fresh water, under sail, at the oars, or at the end of a tow rope - through twelve countries, 282 locks and numerous trails and adventures, including an encounter with Balkan pirates."

Di


To post comments you need to become a member. If you are already a member, please log in .