Login   Sign Up 



 

The Power of the Dark Side is to Heal

by Brian Aird 

Posted: 29 November 2005
Word Count: 544


Font Size
 


Printable Version
Print Double spaced


The concept of an ineluctable human dark side isn't at all popular and some might prefer not to believe it exists, but is does exist; alongside compassion and other worthy virtues. Pretending it isn't there at all is to ignore our own history. It is the human condition; we are all capable of murder, rape, theft, bigotry or bearing false witness just as much as we are capable of sacrificial love and creating things of exquisite beauty.

The same man who goes into war and acts above the call of duty or lays down his life for his friends could also be a wife beater or a criminal, if the conditions occurred to bring that about; there but for fortune go you or I.

If we all recognize our mutual imperfections, then none would think themselves above anyone else or entitled to a greater share of life, love or even life hereafter. The very humbling process of coming to terms with our dark sides should encourage respect and understanding for others. In that sense, the power of the dark side is to heal, because if we recognize defect in ourselves, perhaps we can grow to see goodness in those we hate or see as enemies.

Humans have killed each other with bombs, persecution and all manner of abominable things and none of us are free from guilt just because we didn't serve in any conflicts or sign any military decisions. It really is the human condition that programs us to try to be better than others, to kill, to covert but also to love and to cherish.

Recognizing this is the first step to improving the human condition - refusing to accept it is to perpetuate misunderstanding and ultimately grow the seeds of war. The man or woman I respect most is the one who doesn't think he/she is better than me (morally) but who is prepared to share with me on equal terms.

Our fellow humans in Iraq have an inalienable right to refuse imposed rule, to develop arms and to use them - just as we have done and continue to do. Nor is democracy necessarily better than any other form of government for Iraq. A dictator ship is only as bad as it acts in practice and any particular implementation of democracy can only be judged by its actions. So how many have we killed versus Saddam? How many have we tortured? How many children were deprived because of EU sanctions? How many children were never born because of our intervention? We must look at our own hands to see if they can ever be rubbed clean – the easiest sin to commit is by inaction to prevent injustice. All I did was to write an anti-war protest letter and send it off – how can that have been enough?

We are not free to believe what we want; only what can be shown to be correct. I propose that history proves us to be capable of bloody deeds as much as noble ones. Let's celebrate our shared humanity as it really is and not dissemble or place ourselves above others. I am good and bad, dark and white. I am to blame and I am blameless. Now let us heal.






Favourite this work Favourite This Author


Comments by other Members



scoops at 19:25 on 29 November 2005  Report this post
Brian, There are some interesting thoughts here but where is the focus of the piece? It starts with a juxtapositon of human good versus human evil then moves without a journalistic premise to the situation in Iraq and ends with what appears to be some personal soul searching. What I can see here are parallels in your scenarios but no connectives and none of the polemic that distinguishes a journalistic think piece from an essay or a series of lecture notes:-( I think you must decide which is the most important point you are trying to make and then write into it using a 'peg' - a current event, or an example of the zeitgeist, or a personal experience that ties you to larger events for example. It's an enterprising start and could be worked into something worthwhile:-) Shyama.

Cornelia at 08:31 on 30 November 2005  Report this post
I don't think anyone would contest the idea that there there are benign and destructive elements in human nature - I'm exchewing 'dark side' because of the 'Star Wars' connotations', and 'Good and Evil' because of the biblical connotations; it's mainly men, though, that have all these nasty habits, so mainly men who have to agonise. I don't think all the soul-searching and sentimentalising of aggression, testerone, call it what you will, makes up for it one bit.

If this seems an overly-strong reaction I should explain I am always a bit like this for several weeks after Remembrance Sunday.

Sheila

<Added>

not 'have to agonise'; I mean 'like to agonise'.

Cornelia at 08:38 on 30 November 2005  Report this post
'there but for fortune go you or I.' No, I couldn't become a wife-beater. Why assume your readers are all male?


Beadle at 10:00 on 30 November 2005  Report this post
Brian

There are two quite separate responses I would make to this piece; one regarding the writing itself, and the other the content. However, I don't think that it is easy to separate the two, but I will try.

In terms of the writing, I agree with Scoops that this lacks focus and therefore I would not consider it journalism. It is a collection of opinions referenced by acts of war and violence, with Iraq being the only real example cited.

It rambles along and, if you don't agree with the initial premise that we are all good and bad/just as capable of killing as we are saving lives, then it does nothing to convince the reader or make a strong supporting case for your views and arguments.

So without any of this, it is simply an opinion piece, or a think piece, or a personal view - but one that didn't get me thinking, to be honest.

As for the content, the statement "we are all capable of murder, rape, theft, bigotry or bearing false witness just as much as we are capable of sacrificial love and creating things of exquisite beauty", which is repeated in different way through the piece, is not a view I can agree with.

How do you/we know we are all capable of such things - good or bad - if we haven't done them?

I agree with the view of a dark side that drives us to do things that are dangerous, harmful or wrong, and a better understanding of this, our human failings, would be valuable to stop us putting ourselves above others.

But that doesn't mean that we all have it in ourselves to murder and rape, pre-meditated acts that we SHOULD have control over.

Comparing rapists with killings by invading armies in Iraq is one thing - yes, they are both terrible and unforgivable - but suggesting that both are driven by the same dark place in our hearts is something I cannot agree with.

However misguided we think he is in his belief, Blair thinks he is doing something good for the people of Iraq. The bit of his brain that rationalises this view is unlikely to make him a rapist.

Beadle


Brian Aird at 11:03 on 30 November 2005  Report this post
Thanks for comments everyone. I agree its not journalism, I made far too many unsupported sweeping statements. As it is, the piece is no more that some thoughts I had on my mind that ended up on paper far too quickly. I did try to be provocative though, and I got what I deserved. Next time I'll be more careful.

A journalist I knew once said, 'we write other people's stories.'

Clearly I hadn't referenced what I wanted to say with anyone else's POV. Had I interviewed people involved in a recent war, like Iraq, and limited myself to analyzing what they actually said; that might have been closer to journalism.

Brian


<Added>

What I wrote might boil down to, "If we recognize that there is good and bad in all of us, perhaps we can grow to see goodness in those we hate or see as enemies."

Hardly news worthy.



di2 at 14:08 on 30 November 2005  Report this post
As I read your piece I thought of one of my favourite quotes. Here it is :

"It is impossible to live and not do harm. Equally it is not possible to live without being harmed. So the wise don't say never harm another being, they say 'Do as little harm as possible.' " Source : Roberta Weir author of "Leonardo's Ink Bottle"

I enjoyed your piece.

Di2


To post comments you need to become a member. If you are already a member, please log in .