Login   Sign Up 



 

Attainment - Level 1

by joanie 

Posted: 04 January 2007
Word Count: 51
Summary: This started as a reposnse to the exercise in Poetry Seminar but I think it has taken a different route!


Font Size
 


Printable Version
Print Double spaced


identify
individual
items
in
a
list

Imitate with approximate
pronunciation
and intonation

Respond to individual words
presented in context

Copy familiar words
correctly

identify
with me

I'm the list
of items
making a whole

I can imitate
approximate
intonate

I respond
whether in
or out
of context

My copying is
perfect














Favourite this work Favourite This Author


Comments by other Members



Elsie at 20:02 on 05 January 2007  Report this post
Joan, That was quick -
This has a very melancholy feel to it, a feeling of it being a struggle to put down the words in the right order. It feels like a plea for help, a certain desperation, and a robotic feel.

I think the first four stanzas are taken directly from a kind of test paper - then the following is you taking the idea and going with it - that's my guess. It makes me think of a doll, that can respond, 'intonate and imitate'. There's something quieting and thought provoking about it. The last line is saddest of all - such desperation.


joanie at 20:21 on 05 January 2007  Report this post
Thank you, Elsie. I'm glad it wasn't totally incomprehensible. The first four stanzas are (verbatim) from the National Curriculum Levels - Attainment Targets for Listening, Speaking, Reading, Writing - in Modern Foreign Languages.

I am fascinated by your response; I didn't set out to convey sadness or desperation, but you are absolutely right! Perceptive.

Thanks again!

Joan





Nell at 07:02 on 06 January 2007  Report this post
Hi Joan,

I'm trying to imagine the original document, wondering if the robotic feel has arisen due to the formatting - partly I think. It's definitely there though, particularly in the last four stanzas, which would have quite a different feel if lineated as prose.

I find it slightly worrying that the first four stanzas have been taken verbatim from the NCLs - they're so clinical/unfeeling. The last four stanzas feel to me less like desperation than a complete draining of the narrator, who, having to implement the instructions has herself become programmed/robotic. A clever device, as I know very well you haven't, but it works really well.

A great response - still working with mine - interesting exercise though - thanks Elsie.

Nell.



joanie at 11:19 on 06 January 2007  Report this post
Thanks, Nell. Yes, there is definitely a feeling of losing one's individuality and becoming programmed to deliver in a certain way; robotic isn't so far from the reality.

I'm looking forward to yours!

Joan

DJC at 13:33 on 09 January 2007  Report this post
It does sound robotic, doesn't it! Funny how lineation can do something like this. shows you how important it is.

joanie at 22:11 on 10 January 2007  Report this post
Thanks, Darren. Good to see you. Yes, it's amazing what a difference lineation makes. Fascinating stuff!

Joan


To post comments you need to become a member. If you are already a member, please log in .