Login   Sign Up 



 

TORN - CHAPTER ONE - REVISED

by Joella 

Posted: 18 November 2009
Word Count: 3664
Summary: Following on from the prologue, this chapter sets the foundation for the story. Ben has long protected Roxanne from racist bullies. However, the game is up, denial is no longer an option and he is finally prepared to stand and fight. The consequences will colour his life and have a profound impact upon his future. This has been revised in the light of previous comments. I would appreciate your honest opinions. Thank you.


Font Size
 


Printable Version
Print Double spaced


Content Warning
This piece and/or subsequent comments may contain strong language.


CHAPTER ONE

Friday 3.45pm.
“Oi! Field, yeh dick ‘ead!”
Selby Smith stood blocking our path to the school gate.
Grabbing Roxanne’s hand, “Keep close,” I whispered. “Don’t panic. Keep walking. Just keep walking.”
Swallowed hard, assessing the danger: he wasn’t alone.
“ See yeh’ve still got yeh black bitch wiv yeh,” he spewed.
Adrenaline surged as I took a deep breath, struggling to stay calm. Confidence buoyed by the ‘troop’ baying for my blood Smith swaggered towards us.
“Try to get away,” I whispered, releasing Roxanne.
“ Ben....?”
“ Don’t worry about me. Just run when you can.”

Smith’s retards, Cappy and Ten Bellies, came into view, but Porter was missing. Sensing his imminent deployment, I anticipated their tactic and anxiously awaited Smith’s nod. Flexed fingers formed a clenched fist as punters gathered, jostling for ‘ringside’ position. The arena was shrinking, Roxanne considered escape, but there was nowhere to run.

Gorging on our fear and menacingly shaking his head, “Tried tu teach yeh, Field,” Smith said superciliously, “but yeh neva learn do yeh?”
Smith cued Porter’s rear guard action, but cunning interception, saw his face collide with my fist. Blood spilled from Porter’s mouth, the ‘faithful’ aghast, as he collapsed like a deck chair. He lay cold at my feet, but any hint of satisfaction gleaned from his swift despatch, paled into insignificance to witness Roxanne’s capture. She struggled, cried out, as Smith twisted an arm behind her back.

Burning up, “Let her go.” I demanded, wiping Porter’s blood down my trousers. “It’s me you want,” I reminded, with mock calm and confidence, “so let her go.”
With a grotesque hand stroking her hair, “There, there,” he slimed,“ don’t worry, yeh knight finks yeh wurf savin.’”
Raising the stakes, he molested her breast, savouring my revulsion. Incandescent with rage, I turned my head, as Roxanne broke down. Seeking my submission, he baited me further.
“A good bitch, is she Dick?” he said. “S’pose yeh’d expect niggers to do wot yeh tell ’em.”

Vengeful, caring nothing for my salvation, “Selby you gutless piece of shit,” I cursed, “I’m gunna make you pay, you bastard.” Amused, Smith conducted the crowd. “You’ve always wanted to beat the shit out of me,” I continued, “so now’s your chance.” Anticipating my demise, he pushed Roxanne into Cappy’s clutches. We squared up. Closing in, “C’mon then, you racist bastard,” I goaded. “You’re about to get what you bloody deserve.”

Hungry for first blood, Smith threw a wild punch, missing its target. Not so my response, which caught him square in the face. Blood sprayed from his nose, the crowd gasped, as he swabbed it with a sleeve. Slowly raising his obsidian eyes to mine, spitting blood from his mouth, “I’m gunna fuckin’ kill yeh now, Field,” he snarled. “Yeh shudn’t ‘ave dun that, yeh bastard.”
Roxanne trying in vain to break free, shouted, “Stop! Stop it! No, Ben. Nooooo!”
But it was too late. The game was up: silence could no longer hide his heinous obsession. Morbid curiosity swelled the band of spectators who now moved in, chanting, ‘Fight! Fight! Fight!’

Desperate to restore credibility, Smith came on strong. Arms flailed, we each scored a few points, but forced back into a line of hostile hands, the odds were against me. Shoved from behind, a momentary loss of concentration enabled Smith to take the initiative. Dazed by his fist to my head, a further succession of heavy blows to the body left me doubled over and bleeding. Winded, snatching short sharp breaths, unable to mask the pain, Smith courted adulation to celebrate a premature victory. The atmosphere suddenly fragmented, many were silenced, when, still mopping blood from his face, Smith threatened, “I’m now gunna finish yeh off, Field, yeh wanker.”
Mocking obscenely, spitting, hideously smug, he advanced. Vulnerable, too weak to retaliate, I had but one means of defense, with no margin for error. Slowly, he moved closer, was almost within range, when he stalled to whip up flagging support. I was worried about Roxanne, but dare not take my eyes from Smith. I had but one strike, one chance and it was imperative that I bring him down. Blood from Smith’s nose still ran like a tap, spilling onto his clothes. Drawing an arm across to swab it once more, he turned to face me. Unnerved by such innate malevolence, I swallowed hard. Sensing my fear, crowing with confidence, he closed in for the kill. Swiftly disabled by a foot rammed in his crotch, Smith fell writhing on the ground

Cappy released Roxanne and rushed to his side, as did a handful of his diehard scum bags.“ You’ll pay, Field,” Cappy warned. “You’ll fuckin’ pay for this, you tosser!”

It was no empty threat, there would be retribution, but right now, I had just one concern. Suffering a great deal of discomfort, unsteady and bleeding, I thought only of Roxanne. Mauled and molested, she was inconsolable. I’d failed her, wanted to say sorry but catching her eye briefly, had her freak out. As I approached, she backed away, remonstrating with her hands. Friends trying to calm her insist that I back off - leave her alone and I reluctantly complied.

The arrival of Professor Potts, the Deputy Headteacher, saw the crowd rapidly disperse. Finding Porter and Smith immobilised and bleeding, he called an ambulance and summoned me to this office.

By the time I arrived, Roxanne was in reception with her mother. Mrs Mabula, scowled as I approached, but her daughter, visibly distressed, offered neither word nor gesture. I moved on, but hadn’t travelled far, when I heard..
“BENEDICT FIELD! MY OFFICE. NOW!”

P. Potts, deserving of such ‘title’, was a mountain of a man and his office was a place with which I was far too familiar. He chewed mints to disguise breath laced with alcohol, possessed a volatile temper and I bore him not an ounce of respect. He ushered me into his room and closed the door.
“Your behaviour, Field, was appalling!........,” he began.
I switched off, concentrated only on masking acute pain. Dabbing a bleeding lip, eyes scanned, for the umpteenth time, office walls and shelves displaying a vast array of Second World War memorabilia. He regularly boasted about his military career; claimed to be a war hero, but if that were true, then I was the Archbishop of Canterbury. Lecture almost over, I tuned in.......
“This incident is so serious Field,” he concluded, “that it will have to be thoroughly investigated and may well result in your expulsion from this school...”
I offered no apology, showed not a shred of remorse, obeyed only his demand that I leave.

Needing to get cleaned up before going home, I made my way to the toilets. Rounding a corner, I bumped into Eloise Maye, a relative newcomer to the school. We were not well acquainted, but she refused to let me proceed unattended. With no adult on hand to assist, she collected the first aid box, ‘boasting’ she held a St John’s Ambulance certificate. Her suggestion we go to the girls changing room, met with some protest, but the swathe of her charm and kaleidoscope eyes, won me over.

Removing my jacket, I rinsed blood from my hands and face. Perched at the end of a long bench, Eloise gently tended my wounds, apologizing every time I so much as winced. The changing room door suddenly opened, we caught a breath. It came as a welcome relief to discover it was Emma Carpenter, looking for her coat.

Frowning sympathetically, “In the wars again then, Ben?” she said. “’eard yeh gave Smith and Porter a right pasting. About time. About bloody time too, if yeh ask me. Everyone’s talkin’ about it.” She scanned the room. “ So where’s Roxanne? Why aint she helpin' yeh?”
“She’s not good,” I said. “Her mother’s taken her home.”
Tutting disapprovingly, she walked towards a toilet cubicle, saying, “She dunt know how bloody lucky she is, if yeh ask me.”
Eloise caught my eye, but I looked away.

Cleaned up, I took a peek in the mirror. Disfigured by swellings, cuts and a black eye, I hardly recognized myself. Soothed with various ointments, lotions and a couple of sticky plasters, I thanked Eloise for her time and ‘expert’ attention. She contended it was her pleasure, suggesting,
“Next time, Ben, keep your head down.”
“I’m not planning on making a habit of it,” I assured her.
The toilet flushed and Emma exit the cubicle, straightening her skirt. “ Don’t you believe him, Ellie," she said. "Ben’s been through hell for that girl. A real knight in shining armour, aren’t yeh Ben?” I failed to answer, prompting her to add, “Smith even tried to hang you once, dint he, Ben? And if it weren’t for Miss Holtham comin’ along ......”
“Yeah, well,” I interrupted, increasingly uncomfortable with the topic of conversation,” it’s all in the past. The bastard finally got what he had coming, though I’ll admit it was much less than he bloody deserves”.
They were in agreement with me, but Emma, lifting her coat from a peg, hesitated before warning, “Be careful, Ben. You know Smith and Cappy are evil bastards. They’ll want revenge for what yeh did today.” Then, mouth creasing an impish smile, she was prompted to add, “I ‘eard Selby boasting 'e’s had a swastika tattooed on his ‘arse.”
“Yeah. Probably has,“ I responded, pulling on my jacket, “Goes with the 666 engraved on his head.”
It raised a giggle as we prepared to leave. Parting company just outside the main entrance, I felt a sense of vulnerability, like never before. There could be no more pretense and I was now a bigger target than ever.

Crossing the staff car park I bumped into Mr Dodds. Informed of the fight in a staff meeting, he appeared concerned. I’d missed the school bus and gratefully accepted his offer of a lift home. He suggest that I wait at the end of the drive, adding he’d be ten minutes or so.

Richard Dodds was a teacher with refreshing candour and someone for whom I had the utmost respect. A former ‘Captain of Industry,’ he’d been at the Manor about eight months and was passionate about his profession. True to his word, he soon pulled up along side me in a white Ford Cortina. Wincing, to lower myself into the passenger’s seat, I provided brief directions.

“ Christ, you’re in a lot of bother, Ben,” he warned, as we headed off. “Why? I mean, what ever possessed you to attack Smith and Porter? They’ve been taken to hospital... Selby needs stitches. You broke his nose!” The impassioned crescendo broke as he demonstrated his frustration by smacking a palm against the steering wheel,
“ How the hell are we going to sort this out?” he said. “What have you got to say for yourself, eh?”
“Well, Sir,” I said, emphatically, “ I can’t say I’m sorry, so don’t expect me to apologise. There were a lot of witnesses, but they won’t be able to tell the truth, of course. “ He cast a quizzical glance in my direction. “The ‘Terror’ will prevail, it always does. It doesn’t matter what I say. I tell the truth and I’m still guilty. That’s just how it is, Sir.”
“But why?” he asked, “What the hell is going on?”
“I’m not sure I can say Sir.......Just a personal observation, so better I keep my mouth shut. Besides, no-one would believe me anyway.” Snatching a painful breath, I gazed out of the window, thinking of home.
Breaking an uneasy silence, “ Look, Ben,” he said, “I know you probably don’t trust anyone at school, but I want to help you. The more you tell me, the better informed I’ll be. I want to get to the bottom of this racket. I know something’s going on. The Manor was a good school two years ago and now it’s..... Well, let’s just say it’s not as good as it was. So, anything you tell me will be treated with the strictest confidence, of which you have my absolute assurance.”
After brief contemplation, “If you want to know why the school’s failing, Sir, start at the top. One’s totally incompetent, the other’s a mad alcoholic, which you must have noticed.”
“Well, I’m aware the management is weak.....”
“Weak?” I blurted. “Huh. Non existent, more like. Before Selby Smith arrived, about eighteen months ago, discipline was a dirty word, but look at it now. I’m sure you’ve seen enough to work it out, Sir?”
Mindful, he kept his eyes on the road, whilst I sat staving off an agony born from a deep sense of injustice.
“So, are you saying,” he suggested, thoughtfully,” that the Headteacher offers some sort of favour to Smith and Co. because he helps her maintain order and classroom discipline?”
“To be honest, I don’t know what’s going on, Sir, but classroom clowns seem to have suffered the same fate as the dinosaurs. Okay, teachers still have to put up with the odd prankster, but persistent delinquents, seem to be well off the radar.”
“Yeah,” Mr Dodds commented, “ I think most teachers would agree with you. But surely that’s a good thing, for teachers and pupils, isn’t it?”
“S’pose it is if you don’t want to know why.”
Casting a brief a glance in my direction, “Go on, then” he said. “Enlighten me.”
“An awful lot of disruptive pupils seem to meet with unfortunate accidents.....”
“Only they’re not accidents..?” he anticipated. “Is that what you’re saying?”
“Correct.”
“ But, I still don’t get the connection...”
“ Selby and his ever expanding troop have been known to punish disruptive pupils and get away with it. To me there’s only one explanation, given that Smith is never reported for the beatings. I mean, to an outsider visiting the school, pupils appear well behaved and the Head gets the credit.”
“Mmmn,” Mr Dodds mused, “But how do you fit in? You’re not a disruptive pupil; never thought of you as being aggressive, so why were you and Selby Smith fighting?”
After a few moments, considering my response.
“Trooper, tribute or terror, “ I said, receiving a sideways glance. “In a nut shell, you either join Smith’s band of thugs and agree to obey his rule, buy him off and agree to be silent, or suffer the consequences. Don’t think I’m the only one to stand up to him. There are several prepared to fight for their principles, but Smith has made me his favourite target.”
“But, why?”
“Roxanne. Maybe you haven’t sussed that Smith is a racist bastard: Roxanne’s black. Are you getting the picture, Sir?”
“Yes, Ben,” he said, with an accent of sympathy, “loud and clear.” A fleeting glance of approval framed a sincere smile as he said, ”Sorry I doubted you.”
I mirrored his grin, as he pulled up at the farm's gate. He expressed concern over my injuries, offered to accompany me indoors, help explain what had happened, but this was something only I could do. Grimacing I eased myself out of the car. Winding down his window, Mr Dodds promised to look out for me on Monday. I raised an appreciative hand as he pulled away, beeping his horn.

The house was empty. My mother was away until Tuesday, visiting a sick friend and I guessed grandpa would be pottering around outside. Left hand painfully swollen, I made up an ice pack and wrapped it round. Upstairs, in the solace of my room, I rested on the bed. Alone, responding to the pain, everything hurt. Physically and mentally drained, I was consoled only by the knowledge that I was safe. I was always safe here and, for now, that was comfort enough.

Merryfields had been my home since my father died almost eleven years ago. Grandpa took me in when my mother suffered a breakdown. I soon grew to love him and in time we become, to each other, that which had been lost from our lives. Every day on his farm was a new adventure. He taught me to ride; took me fishing; let me sit with him on the tractor; brought a whole new dimension to my life. In the beginning, I missed my dad, kept expecting him to walk in through the door. But fragile memories fade and in time, I learned to move on.

Creaking stairs alerted me to grandpa’s imminent arrival. Bracing myself, he entered, visibly shocked to discover me as he did. Quizzing me with his eyes, he perched on the edge of the bed. He’d seen Smith’s trade mark numerous times before, not that he'd have known it. Now, with nothing to lose, before a question was raised, I confessed everything, with the honesty he richly deserved. It was difficult, not so much to explain the injuries, as it was to expose the deceit...
“So all those rugby scrapes, mishaps, accidents, were........”
“Lies,” I interrupted. “I lied to hide the truth because I was afraid Roxanne’s parents would take her away........ Sorry. I know I shouldn’t have deceived you and mum .....”
“Hey,” he said, gently touching my arm, “You did what you thought was right, son. Maybe you shouldn’t have allowed yourself to suffer, but I understand why you did. Love,” he commended. “Yes, no doubt you felt a a sense of honour too, but you did it to protect someone you love. Right?”
I nodded, wiped away tears, as the magnitude of what had happened cast all comfort aside. Recognising my anguish, grandpa provided reassurance, said I wasn’t alone: we stood shoulder to shoulder and the incident would not go unchallenged. The phone rang and he went off to answer it.

I phoned Roxanne in the evening, to discover she was still feeling unwell. However, we chatted briefly, time enough to say I was sorry I failed her. She refused to accept any form of apology, contended it wasn’t my fault. I wanted to see her and she promised to visit ‘tomorrow’.

Numerous ice packs reduced swellings considerably, but Roxanne still gasped and slid her eyes from mine, when I welcomed her the following afternoon. We climbed the stairs to my room and closing the door, I instantly noted an opaque sadness in her eyes.
“Sorry, Ben,” she said, lip quivering. “Sorry I couldn’t stay with you on Friday. I didn’t mean to push you away. It’s just that the sight of blood freaks me out.“
She started to tremble. Concerned, I moved to comfort her. Breathing deeply, tears welled as she stole a moment to compose herself.
“I don’t like blood or loud bangs,” she began. “I’m scared of guns and thunder. In Nigeria..." hesitating to gaze out of the window, "I was holding the hand of my father’s friend when he was shot dead.” Trembling, face fraught with unwelcome recollection, “His blood splattered all over me.” Closing her eyes, tears spilled onto her cheeks as she recalled, “It was awful. Awful!”
Sobbing, she turned to press her head against my chest.
My insides fluttered as I held her in a close embrace, stroking her hair, “You’re safe now," I said softly. " Every-thing's going to be okay. Don’t talk about it.”
She pulled away, hand wiping her eyes, to continue, “I had nightmares for a long time. Mum brought me back to England. I didn’t speak for two months.... That’s when we met at school, remember?”
“Yeah,” I beamed, passing her a box of tissues. “I thought you were dumb, then one morning playing kiss chase, you asked me to marry you! Six. Six years old and we were almost married.”
She giggled, we both did, which brought a moment of welcome relief.

Wrapping up against the winter chill, we went to see the horses in the barn. Roxanne clambered up to sit on Liberty and if I’d been fit, I’d have sat with her.
“Did anyone help you at school after the fight?” she asked, grabbing a handful of Libby’s mane to steady herself.
“Yeah,” I said, hesitantly. “Eloise did. She patched me up.”
She bit down on her lip, looked away, made no comment, then she didn’t need to. Roxanne had a distinct dislike of Eloise, though she wouldn’t say why.
“What did your parents say about what happened?” I enquired, nervously, as she ran her hand up and down Libby’s neck.
“Much as we always feared,” came a melancholy response. Looking down into my eyes, “I’m not going back to the Manor. My father forbids it.“
I hung my head, took a disconsolate breath. “ So what about us?" I asked in a negative mood. "Can we still see each other?”
“Yeah. Of course, “ she assured, gleefully. “And we can phone each other, can’t we?”
“ It won’t be the same at school without you.” Sighing deeply, “I’ll miss you, Rox.... It all seems for nothing now...”
“No, Ben. Don’t say that,” she replied, reassuringly. “It’s all going to work out in the end, you’ll see.”
“Wish I could believe that,” I said, as she slid from my horse to stumble into my arms. Looking into her beautiful ebony eyes, I caught a delicious breath. I was on the verge of saying, ‘I love you,’ but a moment’s hesitation allowed the golden opportunity to slip away.

Cold, we returned to the house and messed about in my room. When the time came for her to leave, I walked her to the front door.
“See you next week, then,“ she said, gingerly, kissing my cheek.
“I’m looking forward to it already,” I replied, forcing a smile. “Maybe you could stay a bit longer?”
She caught my eye, agreed to ask her mother and promised to phone on Monday. Roxanne climbed into the car. I waved. She blew a kiss and as the Mercedes pulled away, I was struck by a sense of foreboding: a deepening suspicion that all was not well...





































F







Favourite this work Favourite This Author


Comments by other Members



NicciF at 10:14 on 21 November 2009  Report this post
Hi Joella

This is excellent, gripping stuff. You have an economy of words that increases the tension and pace of the chapter. Having read this I can now understand why some people commenting on the Prologue were surprised about it being the same writer. Whilst the Prologue had intrigue and mystery it slightly lacked the edginess that this has. Perhaps later on, when we know more about the plot and characters, we should revisit the Prologue. I’m not suggesting removing it, just working out how to improve it in line with the rest of the book.

I have one general questions before I go through a list of nits.

What age is Ben? I’ve estimated him to be about 16. If he is a lot older/younger some my comments will need to be adjusted slightly.

So going through in strict order these are my specific comments. There will be a lot of them as the chapter is fairly long. However, none of them are huge, so don’t panic. I looks as if I have written a huge amount, but I assure you this is more to do with me attempting to clearly identify the section that I’m referring to and not to the amount of “errors” that I found. It’s so much easier with a paper copy and a red pen!

Also just to let you know, where I’ve suggested an alternative I’ve highlighted them in italics in the vain hope that this makes them easier to read.

[quote]”Oi! Field, yeh Dick ‘ead!”

Great opening. Should it be a lower case “d” after all we’re not referring to someone’s name!

[quote]Selby Smith, stood blocking …[/quote]
I don’t think the comma is needed.

[quote]Swallowing hard, assessing the danger[/quote]
Consider changing to [I]I swallowed hard, assessing the danger[/I]

[quote]Confidence buoyed by the ‘troop’ baying for my blood, Smith swaggered towards us.[/quote]
Brilliant image – don’t think you need the comma after “blood”.

[quote] Releasing Roxanne, “try to get way,” I whispered.[/quote]
Perhaps changing the order would make this work better ie “Try to get away,” I whispered, releasing Roxanne.

[quote]The arena was shrinking, Roxanne looked to escape, but there was nowhere to run. [/quote]
Great stuff – perhaps change “to escape” to “considered escape”.

[quote]tutting and shaking his head[/quote]
“tutting” doesn’t fit in with what’s happening and impedes the building tension. What about [I]and menacingly shaking …[/I]

[quote]Smith said superciliously, but yeh neva learn do yeh?“ [/quote]
Typo problem with quotation marks – missing before “but” and wrong direction after “yeh?”.

[quote]He cued Porter’s rear guard action, but cunning interception, saw his face collided with my fist.[/quote]
It took me a couple of reads to establish who the “He” and this “his” were. I eventually worked out that Smith cued Porter’s rear guard and it was Porter’s face. Having to stop and work this out reduces the tension. A very minor edit will soon sort this out.

[quote]”There, there,” he slimed, “Don’t worry.. “[/quote]
It should be a lower case “d” after the comma. Also I was always taught to keep to simple “said” in dialogue. The occasion “whisper/shouted” is also acceptable. However, I can imagine the disgusting tone of his voice which makes the reader want to cringe. In order to keep that element how about [I] “There, there” he said, his voice slimy and full of leering suggestion/overtones/undertones/something. “Don’t worry, yeh knight …”[/I]

[quote]Incandescent with rage, as Roxanne broke down, I turned my head. [quote]
The image is great, the sentence construction/order of the 3 elements made me stumble slightly. Perhaps [I]As Roxanne broke down I turned my head, incandescent with rage.[/I] or [I]Incandescent with rage, I turned my head as Roxanne broke down.[/I] would be better.

[quote] Seeking my submission, he bating me further.[quote]
Type – “baited”.

[quote]Vengeful, now caring nothing ….”You’re about to get what you bloody deserve.”
I think this is all Ben speaking. If this is the case the person who conducted the crowd almost comes across as Ben too. Although I think this is/or should be Selby. To clarify this consider [I]Amused Smith/Selby conducted the crowd.[/I]

[quote]Morbid curiosity expanded the band of spectators who now closed in, chanting.[/quote]
I know what you mean, however, using the words “expanded” and “closed in” in the same sentence almost seems like a contradiction in terms.

[quote]I was worried about Roxanne, but dare not avert my eyes from Smith.[/quote]
Perhaps “take” instead of avert, which seems too adult a word.

[quote]Swiftly disabled by a boot in his crotch, Smith fell writhing at my feet, mumbling unintelligibly. [/quote]

Yeh – way to go Ben. I bet that felt good. “A boot” jars a little. Perhaps “my boot” would be better, although you then have a repetition of “my” in the sentence. Perhaps you don’t need the “at my feet”. So the whole thing would read – [I]Swiftly disabled by my boot in his crotch, Smith fell writhing, mumbling unintelligibly, to the floor/ground.[/I]

[quote]Cappy, released Roxanne and rushed to his side, as did a handful of his diehard …[/quote]
Don’t think you need the comma after “Cappy”. Perhaps you need followers or something similar are “diehard”.

[quote] but right now, I had but one concern. [/quote]
Repetition of “but” and the “I had but one concern” doesn’t sound like Ben – too old/formal, perhaps consider changing the 2nd “but” to “just”.

[quote]Roxanne was in reception with her mother, by the time I arrived.[/quote]
Not sure that the comma is needed. Also consider changing the order to the sentence to [I]By the time I arrived Roxanne was in reception with her mother.[/I]

Joella I’m very conscious of the amount that I’ve written so far and I only got to the end of the 1st scene. As I said at the beginning they are very tiny little comments, most of them typos and the odd rouge comma/quotation mark. I want to make sure that you are happy with this level of feedback before I continue. I have gone through to the end of the chapter, so from my point of view it’s just a case a typing everything up. I want to assure you that there is nothing drastic in the remainder of the chapter – it really is main typos etc. but I want to know that I’m not being too nit-picky.

You have a wonderful style, the beginnings of a great plot. I’m starting to associate with Ben, feel concern for Roxanne and want to finish what Ben started with Smith and Potter. I also want to know how all of this ties in with the prologue and all this in just a few pages is brilliant.

Nicci

<Added>

Joella

I've just noticed that my quotes and italics don't appear to have worked. If this is a nightmare for you to read and understand please let me know and I sort something out. I've writen the original in word, so I can always go back to my original notes if necessary.

Nicci


Joella at 11:08 on 21 November 2009  Report this post
Hi Nicci, thank you for such a detailed crit. I want to improve this piece, so have no problem with your comments. Fire away, I can take it. Regards, Joella.

NicciF at 12:07 on 23 November 2009  Report this post
Hi Joella

Sorry about the delay in posting the next lot of nits. I wanted to give someone else a change to comment. Here they are. Again lots of little tiny things, so nothing to worry about. I've read through the chapter again and still think it's brilliant. Needs a little polishing, however, it's got everything. A great mc I'm starting to care about. A badie/bully I want to hit. There's tension and young love. As I said "brilliant".

Nicci

Here's part 2 if you're sitting down!

[quote]possessed a volatile temper, which warrant not a modicum of respect. [/quote]
Should it be “warranted”? Although I think the whole phrase might be a little too adult for Ben.

[quote]eyes canned for the umpteenth time, office walls and shelves [/quote]
Don’t think you need the comma.

[quote]but the swathe of her charm and kaleidoscope eyes, had me acquiesce.[/quote]
Lovely description. Possibly change “acquiesce” as many be too adult a word for Ben.

[quote]It came a s a welcome relief that it was Emma Carpenter [/quote]
Typo “a s a”

[quote]Tutting, disapprovingly [/quote]
Again not too sure about the use of “tutting” Perhaps add more disapproving words to Emma’s dialogue.

[quote]The toilet flushed and as Emma exit the cubicle, straightening her skirt, “Don’t you believe him, Ellie,” [/quote]
What about this instead – The toilet flushed and Emma exited the cubicle straightening her skirt. “Don’t’ you …”

[quote]Yeah, well.” I interjected, increasingly [/quote]
“Interjected” – too adult for Ben.

[quote]but Emma, lifting her coat from a peg, hesitated, to warn [/quote]
Perhaps hesitated before warning would be better.

[quote]He suggested that I wait at the end of the drive, said he’d be ten minutes or so.[/quote]
Perhaps change “said” to “adding”.

[quote]he’d been in post about eight months [/quote]
I know exactly what “in post” means as I expect most other readers will, however, I’m not sure that Ben would use this phrase. Perhaps at the school would be better.

[quote]The impassioned crescendo broke and having demonstrated [/quote]
Consider replacing “and having” with “as he”. Lovely description/image.

[quote]Just a personal observation, so Better[/quote]
Lower case “b”.

[quote]Before Selby Smith arrived, some eighteen months ago, [/quote]
As this is Ben actually talking consider replacing “some” with “about”.

[quote]whilst I sat staving an agony [/quote]
Missing “off” after “staving”. Again a brilliant insight into how Ben’s feeling.

[quote]”Selby and his ever expanding troop, have been known to punish disruptive pupils and get away with it. To me there is only one explanation, given the fact that Smith is never reprimanded for the beatings. [/quote]
As this is Ben talking I think the following minor changes will make it read better/fit more with his voice. Either insert a comma after “Selby” or remove the one after “troop”. Contract “there is” to “there’s”. Remove “the fact” and change “reprimanded” for a less adult word.

[quote]you either join Smith’s Band of thugs[/quote]
Typo – I think is should either be “Band of Thugs” or band of thugs”.

[quote]A fleeting glance of approval, framed a sincere smile, as he said[/quote]
Don’t think you need either commas.

[quote]Unmasked, responding to the pain, everything hurt.[/quote]
You’re really there with Ben. Unmasked a little too adult so consider a slight change to either Alone at last and responding[/I] or [I]Alone, responding

[quote]since my father died almost eleven years ago[/quote]
and
[quote]I missed my dad, kept expecting him…[/quote]
I’m now confused about Ben’s age. If, as I suspect, he’s about 16 then he would have been about 5 when his dad died. If he was this young I’m not 100% sure that Ben would have enough memories to still remember, and miss, his dad 11 yrs later. I can certainly remember major things that happened to me a that sort of age, so he’d certainly have some memories, however, missing him might be pushing it.

Just had a thought – as Ben’s talking about when he started his new life with his Grandpa does the “I missed my dad” referred to that period of time? If this is the case, perhaps you need an In the beginning I missed my dad, kept … I tripped up on Ben’s age in this paragraph which distracted me from the tension that you’d carefully built. Just concerned that if it happened to me, then it could make other readers take a step back too.

[quote] “You did what you thought was right, son” May be you … [quote]
A rouge quotation marks slipped in after “son”.

[quote]but Roxanne still gasped and briefly averted her eyes, when I [/quote]
I think you need a comma after “gasped”.

[quote]querying the source of such anguish. [/quote]
Too adult a phrase. Perhaps consider something like confused by the extent of her aguish

[quote]My insiders fluttered and as I held her in a close embrace[/quote]
Awww – young love! Don’t think you need the “and”.

[quote]looked away, made no comment, then she didn’t need to.[/quote]
I personally hate the word, however, I think you need a “but then”

[quote]I said. “I’ll miss you, Rox ….Sighing deeply,[quote]
Consider changing the order slightly to I said, sighing deeply, “I’ll miss you, Rox ….

[quote]‘I love you,’ but a moment’s hesitation, allowed the golden opportunity to slip away.[/quote]
Oh No! Men or boys! Why wont they take a risk and say what’s on their mind. Not sure that you need the comma after “hesitation”.

[quote]Gingerly, kissing my cheek, “See you next week, then,” she said.[/quote]
The order seems a little cack-handed. What about ”See you next week, then,” she said, gingerly kissing my cheek.

[quote]Roxanne climbed into the car. I waved, she blew a kiss, but as the Merceedes pulled away, I was struck by a sense of foreboding, a deepening suspicion that all was not well … [/quote]

A great ending, however, I think is looses a little of its impact by the length of the sentence and the number of commas. I might read better as Roxanne climbed into the car. I waved. She blew a kiss but as the Merceedes pulled away I was struck by a sense of foreboding. A deepening suspicion that all was not well …

There – I did say that it was just lots of little nits. Important to highlight, especially the typo which I can spot in other’s work but not my own!

Phew - hope I haven't totally overpowered/bored you

Nicci


Joella at 14:34 on 23 November 2009  Report this post
Thanks, Nicci. I've made a lot of changes in light of your comments. I so appreciate the time you spent doing this. Really can't thank you enough!! Joella.

NicciF at 17:39 on 23 November 2009  Report this post
Hi Joella

I'm glad that this has helped you. I know it's helped me because I'm learning to review my own work in the same way, which means that my writing should improve, which is also a bonus.

I've made a lot of changes in light of your comments.

Remember that these are only one person's opinions (and I'm no expert). So only change things that "ring true" with your knowledge of what Torn is about and where it is heading in the future.

Really can't thank you enough!!

Thanks for saying this. It has been my pleasure. Torn has the potential to be really really good, so helping you see and realise its potential is thanks enough

Nicci


Joella at 18:07 on 23 November 2009  Report this post
You're much to generous with your praise, Nicci. But I will persevere until I'm happy it's as good as it can be. Thanks again, Joella.

jim60 at 09:39 on 24 November 2009  Report this post
Hi Joella, sorry it's taken me a while to get to your chapter. The first thing that got me was the word count, 7355 and thought blimey! Anyway, let's get to the nitty gritty.
Very well done, I was drawn to Ben with a lot of sympathy, being drawn into that and doing what he feels is right and that was written well. The bad guys were bad, how they should be. I see that Nicci has had a good go already and I'm not going to add anything, cos I can't. I'm looking to see the next chapter and if it holds as this one did.
Jim.


Joella at 17:56 on 24 November 2009  Report this post
Hi Jim, thanks for reviewing this chapter. Thanks too for alerting me to the word count. It should be 3664 words, only for some reason, the piece was duplicated. I've now deleted the copy. It's good to get a male point of view, as I'm trying to get inside Ben's head. If you read any more and think - no way - a lad wouldn't think / do that, please let me know. Thanks again, Jim.
Joella.

Demonqueen at 14:48 on 25 November 2009  Report this post
Hi Joella,
I'm afraid I haven't time to read all of this as have to pick up the LO from nursery, but I have skimmed through (as I did read the whole of last version).

This is much, much cleaner narrative than last time. This is especially important for the very first sentences. You've improved that exponentially while still keeping us thrown in at the deep end. None of the tension or atmosphere has been lost by changing it. I followed the fight scene much easier than last time.

There are some punctuation errors which mostly look like typos (missing commas or full-stops), so you'll need to go through it meticulously when you come to your final draft. While we're on the subject of punctuation, is there a particular reason you use double speech marks? It's just that in UK I thought it was the done thing to use single ones. I ask because I wondered if you were using American punctuation rules.

[quote]With a grotesque hand stroking her hair, “There, there,” he slimed,“ don’t worry, yeh knight finks yeh wurf savin.’”[/quote]

If using British punctuation, I think you'd need to lose the comma after 'hair' as it is not describing the act of speech. And this may be true of 'he slimed' as well, though I think debateable. You may want to double check it.
But if you are using American punctuation, it may not matter, though I don't know about the differences with American punctuation to state that as a fact.

[quote]but catching her eye briefly, had her freak out[/quote] I would lose the comma here, it's not needed and makes the sentence read funny

[quote]Wincing, to lower myself into the passenger’s seat, I provided brief directions.[/quote]
He had to wince in order to lower himself into the seat? And why the comma after wincing? Do you mean, 'wincing, I lowered myself into the passenger seat'? The first two sections of your sentence don't make sense when they stand alone and the last section does, so probably should be a sentence on its own or sew it onto the end of your sentence with 'and I provided brief directions.'

{quote]“I know you probably don’t trust anyone at school,[/quote]

How does he know that, and why does he think that?

[quote]“ Selby and his ever expanding troop have been known to punish disruptive pupils and get away with it. To me there’s only one explanation, given that Smith is never reported for the beatings. I mean, to an outsider visiting the school, pupils appear well behaved and the Head gets the credit.”[/quote]

I am still finding this scenario difficult to buy into. I know you are giving your reader an explanation as to why the MC is getting into trouble and not the instigator, but I don't find it believable. I'm sorry, I don't want to sound like I am poo-pooing your hard work but these are the thoughts that crossed my mind when I read this:

How can this fake representation of the pupils(the one the head wants to portray) hold any weight if there are kids being beaten for mucking around at school? Wouldn't their parents step in? Complain? The kind of beatings you're referring to wouldn't go unnoticed.
And how does the head teacher work out a few 'class clowns' are worse than a violent bully who draws blood?
Surely this Selby character must have something over the head if he is allowed to continue like this maybe he is blackmailing him/her (sorry, I forget who is the head!)? If this is the case then I would throw in a few hints and leave the reader to do the guess work for a few chapters, rather than having your MC explain it all away from the start.

Right, You'll be relieved to hear I've got to go!

It's getting there, Joella. I hope this Selby bloke gets what he deserves!

Look forward to the next chapter,

TTFN

Charlie

Candiflare at 19:34 on 25 November 2009  Report this post
Hi Joella,

I started this and I couldn't stop reading it. I thought it was fantastic. In fact, I've read it twice! If this was the first chapter of a book, I'd buy it in a trice. In fact, it made me think of all the fiction I've tried to read in the past, but ended up losing interest and wondering why it couldn't have been more like yours!

I don't have a criticism of it, unfortunately, as I know you really want it to be the best it can be. I think other fiction writers with more authority than me (I can't write fiction, only non-fiction!) might be able to help you with something constructive (I see Nicci has already had a go) but all I can say to you is that when it's published, I'll buy it!

Joella at 19:47 on 25 November 2009  Report this post
Hi Charlie and thank you so much for reading this again and offering such helpful comments. I'm glad you think it has been improved. I will take on board all that you said and make changes where needed. Regards, Joella

Joella at 20:05 on 25 November 2009  Report this post
Hi Candiflare and thanks for the compliment. I'm glad you like this story. I was especially pleased to hear you say that you found it very readable. I know what you mean about starting a book and wondering why you bothered. What you've said is truly appreciated. Thank you, Joella.

NicciF at 21:02 on 25 November 2009  Report this post
Hi Joella

Glad to see that you've got some other feedback to counter-balance mind and give you a more varied set of opinions.

I've just had one more thought. I know that the bully's name is Selby Smith. I notice that Ben swaps between using his first and last names. Perhaps you need to be more consistant and always use "Smith" and it can be a little confusing.

Alternatively use Smith unless Ben is talking to an adult.

Just a minor point and one easiliy rectified using "find & replace" in word if you think it a valid one.

Nicci


Joella at 18:15 on 26 November 2009  Report this post
Thanks Nicci. Funnily enough, I had the same thought. Good idea. I'll do that. Joella

NicciF at 08:01 on 01 December 2009  Report this post
Hi Joella

Hope the polishing is going well. Let us know if you want us to look at the revised version.

Nicci



To post comments you need to become a member. If you are already a member, please log in .