Login   Sign Up 



 

Hamburg 1941

by McAllerton 

Posted: 25 April 2010
Word Count: 656
Summary: A child, an air raid, Christmas time. A very short short story.


Font Size
 


Printable Version
Print Double spaced


HAMBURG 1941

You are eight years old, sitting at the table with your little brother and sister. Your mother is wiping the table and your faces. She has done her best on poor rations. You havenÕt seen your father for a long time. He is fighting in Russia with the other fathers for the Fatherland.

Christmas is in the air and on the faces of the little ones, Liese and Hans. Tonight is the night St Nicholas will come and knock at your door. You are above all this because you are the eldest, the man of the house, but you feel the thrill singing in your gut.

The doorbell rings and little Liese starts the chant, ÒItÕs him, itÕs him, let him in, let him in.Ó

You go to the door while your mother wipes her hands on her apron, and pats her hair. Liese and Hans run to her. Smiling and cooing, she kneels and shelters them with her arms crooked like folded wings while they cling and peep.

You let him in and hold the door as he stamps in with his mitre and crook. You notice he wears black socks and ordinary shoes under his red robes. When he turns to you there is black stubble under his cotton wool beard.

ÒGood evening sir. Are there any good children here?Ó he ruffles your hair. You point to the little ones, who shrink further into your motherÕs arms. ÒI have presents for good children.Ó

You laugh as you watch them and your thumb finds its way into your mouth.

ÒAh, a naughty boy who sucks his thumb,Ó he says and you whip both hands behind your back.

ÒCarl,Ó your mother says. ÒI thought youÕd stopped that, what would your father say?Ó

Heat floods your face and you fight back tears. St Nicholas coaxes the little ones to hold out hands for presents. He smiles at you, offers a present, ruffles your hair again.

ÒCome on, little man,Ó he says. ÒPromise to be good and not suck your thumb and you can have a present.Ó

Your hands stay locked behind your back. He shrugs and puts your present on the table, the damage done.

That night you are in the air raid shelter with your family and neighbours. You are cold in the dark and hear whispering and praying between the crumps and thuds of bombs.

ÒWill St Nicholas be safe?Ó asks Liese.

The bombs go on and on. You pray for your mother, father, Liese and Hans. You think about death, black and final. Your mother has told you that heaven is light and everlasting. You think about Jesus and all of you sleeping and floating on clouds. You try to ignore the smell of urine from your pyjamas.

The dawn brings the all clear and you stumble out into the street holding your brotherÕs hand. There are fires and gaps where tidy houses stood yesterday. The smashed houses have been scattered across the street. You crunch through glass, stub your toes on broken bricks and mortar, and tiptoe around puddles of dirty water. You hear firemen giving orders and hushed voices of onlookers. The smells of burning timber and broken gas mains mix with new smells, which you think are death. In a row on the pavement there are mounds covered with grey blankets.

ÒWalk with me, meine Kinder,Ó your mother says. ÒDonÕt look.Ó

You cannot tear your eyes from the mounds as you pass near them. You see a pair of feet in black shoes and socks sticking out from one of the blankets. Your mother does not see you approach and lift the blanket. His face is covered in dust and dirt but you notice the stubble still there beneath his white beard, now askew. The blank eyes of St Nicholas look into nowhere. Dropping the blanket over his face you turn to your brother and say ÒServes him right.Ó









Favourite this work Favourite This Author


Comments by other Members



Katerina at 22:13 on 25 April 2010  Report this post
Hi Andy - and Mark,

Well according to all the sources I looked at, both rationing and the bombing were later.

There was some isolated bombing of German towns in 1940/41, but no concerted bombing efforts until 42 and 43.

As for rationing, they weren't short of anything in Germany until the latter years of the war.

Obviously different sources have different information, so I guess it depends which one you want to use.

Kat



<Added>

Just found this -

Food Availability (1939-42)
The success of the Wehrmacht in the first years of the War made it possible for the NAZIs to spare German civilians at home from deprivations experienced during World War I. This was accomplished by two expedients. First, slave labor including POWs was used to prevent agricultural production from plumetting. Second, the NAZIs ruthlessly plundered the food production of occupied countries. Thus food was still easily available in Germany during the first years of the War. Rationing was introduced, but it was not severe. The Germans thus had much better diets than the British who were forced to introduce a very strict raioning program which strictly regulated the consumption of meats, dairy proucts and eggs, sugar, and other foods.

I'm not trying to be pedantic, but I felt that you were trying to convey a sense of depravation in the story, which didn't exist in 1941 in Hamburg.

As for the bombing, serious saturation bombing night after night didn't really occur until later, so I felt that what you were trying to portray occured later than 1941.

Anyway, it's no big deal, it's a fictional story not a historical essay!

I still enjoyed it :)



McAllerton at 22:47 on 25 April 2010  Report this post
I'm not sure why the text is hard to read for others. It looks fine on my iMac. I'll ask Writewords admin about it.

fluffyduffy at 13:00 on 26 April 2010  Report this post
Hi Mark,

I just wanted to say that I enjoyed this. It was simple but said so much all at the same time. Giving the reader an insight on life for the families affected by the war and how they did their best to bring hope to the children in such terrible times.

I'm afraid my history knowledge is pretty poor, so I can't comment on the rationing and bomb shelters - I was one of the kids who sat at the back of the class, gossiping when I should have been listening to my history teacher ;-)

I don't have any comments that haven't already been said, i'm afraid.

I do have one question though, during that time would it have been St. Nicolas, Father Christmas or Santa? See, I told you my history was terrible.

Anyway, I thought this was very well written.

Thank you for sharing.

Alana

tec at 04:30 on 27 April 2010  Report this post
Hi Mark, I too enjoyed reading this and thought the style was clear, direct, perfect to convey the experience of an 8 year old. I am not sure why you chose second person for the story but I think it worked. I do agree with Andy however - both on the formatting and on the last line. The formatting issues were very troublesome! I almost didn't make it to the end! Maybe convert the file to text before you post it? It must be a Mac/Windows thing. I also found the last line very jarring and to undercut the emotional current of the story. Was it meant to be funny? You create such pathos for the MC, he seems such a complicated, serious little guy, and it doesn't seem he would say such a thing.

thanks for posting, I enjoyed reading this

Tara



Becca at 10:35 on 27 April 2010  Report this post
Hi Mark,
I'm in accord with the comments above on the clarity of the writing, but also on the tone of the ending. It would be difficult, I think, for an adult or child to feel vengeful in such a terrible situation, and in the end, the St. Nicholas figure probably said no more to the boy than his own mother might have said about thumb sucking. Maybe if he hadn't been allowed any presents, the ending would've made more sense - but even so ....
I have a sense that this story could be enlarged and fleshed out more, as Kat mentioned, so that the readers could get closer to the characters.
Becca.

McAllerton at 20:53 on 27 April 2010  Report this post
Dear all

Thanks for your comments.

I'll double check the facts for authenticity.

I wasn't sure about using the second person, just thought I'd give it a try after reading a short story by Petina Gappah in the same style which seemed to work. I'm glad the style seemed OK as it's not often used.

There are evidently mixed views about the ending. I wanted to describe a child viewing a tragic situation in a completely unexpected way by thinking only about his own feelings of resentment. It seemed plausible that in the midst of all the difficulties of wartime (the absence of his father, the air raids, possible death, the expectation that he might be asked to act like an adult towards his siblings but without the emotional maturity to do so) he might shock people by responding in a very childish and egocentric way. I tried to get across some of the worry that he is carrying around with the section in the shelter when he fears death and wets himself. Eight years of age is a time when children are beginning to relate big ideas like death to themselves, but they are still very young and I wanted him to be worried to death but trying to please his mother. In the middle of such worries and trauma, he might be easily hurt by an off-hand adult comment. Adults often don't realise how children interpret seemingly innocuous comments.

I'll look at the ending again, but I'm reluctant to change it for another reason. It's a true story. I heard an elderly German in a TV documentary talking about an air raid when he was a boy. Father Christmas visited his shelter and upset him with an off-hand comment. The boy saw his body the next morning and thought 'serves him right'. When I heard this it pulled me up short and stuck in my head, hence the story. How much should I change a story that really happened? Obviously, if readers find it hard to believe I need to look at the text and see if I can change anything to make it more so without changing the ending.

Fluffyduffy: Germans call FC St Nicholas (unless I'm wrong on that fact too!)

Best wishes

Mark


Becca at 07:36 on 28 April 2010  Report this post
Hi Mark,
I can understand your reluctance to change the ending, and sometimes there just needs to be more in the text that leads up to the end point to make it credible, so I'd try that. Perhaps something about his relationship with his mother could do the trick, if he is now 'man of the house' he'd have a sense of having to protect her, so maybe St Nicholas can become the abstract enemy.
Becca.

Katerina at 19:45 on 28 April 2010  Report this post
Hi Mark,

Well I actually liked the ending because it kind of shows that although he's meant to be the man of the house, he is still very much a child.

Maybe you could have him blurt out to his brother 'serves him right', and then when reality sinks in that St Nicholas is dead he can start to cry or something?

Kat x

Crimsondelilah at 20:08 on 28 April 2010  Report this post
Hi Mark. I can't speak for the authenticity of the facts but this does read well. I usually find the use of the second person quite difficult but in a work of this length, it works for me. I've read the consensus about your ending but I take the opposite view. Yes it is a harsh and callous statement, but in my opinion, children like adults are not saints and can sometimes be cruel as a way of dealing with uncomfortable or humiliating situations. Perhaps you could add more about how mortified he feels as the man of the house to be put on the spot by a stranger about sucking his thumb. Kat's suggestion has some merit as well, allowing the reality of St Nichola's death and what he has said, to really sink in. But I wouldn't have a problem if you left it as is.

eedel9kvr at 18:46 on 29 April 2010  Report this post
Hi Mark,

Just wanted to say that I enjoyed your story. I have read the others views on your ending and while I agree it is probably uncharacteristic for an 8 yr old to react in such a way, I also think we have to allow for the fact that it was set during wartime, when normal behavior was suspended during extraordinary times.

I thought maybe the boy had recognized the man who was dressed as St Nick, maybe he had been visiting the boys mother regularly ; and the boy was afraid his father was being ousted - circumstances like this would justify his outburst.

Thats just my take on things, feel free to ignore.

Edel



bjlangley at 12:25 on 30 April 2010  Report this post
Hi,

I think you have used the second person really well, it was incredibly effective.

With such a short story you have done well to bring us in to the scene, but there were a could of bits I thought we needed to see more - "She has done her best on poor rations." I felt this was an example of where you are telling instead of showing, and it took me out of the story a little.

Also towards the end the mix between English and German dialogue didn't work for me - walk with me meine kinder - as in reality they would be speaking German, but you narrative choice would be to translate for the reader - having it half and half suggests this is how she said it.

I had a few issues with the ending - I didn't think 'look into nowhere' worked for St Nic's eyes, and his words to his brother made him seem callous. I can understand your relunctance to change it, so maybe just something minor? I would expect him to shield his brother from seeing that - keep his brother's belief alive as part of his 'man of the house' role, even if he mutters 'serves him right' under his own breath?

All the best,

Ben


To post comments you need to become a member. If you are already a member, please log in .