Login   Sign Up 



 

Opening of novel `Cut`

by Mia-S 

Posted: 02 December 2016
Word Count: 1316


Font Size
 


Printable Version
Print Double spaced


Stunted creature crouched on bed throttling someone to death - broken neck, dark ... coming for me.
In and out of sleep; waking to nothing.
The last seven weeks have been hell.  More than that, nine weeks, but seven weeks ago you left and that was that.  It was why you were shaking, drawn, days and days, eleven, without a call.
8.24, the night is through.  You don’t want me anymore.  Whilst I’ve been rotting you’ve been with her, holding, smiling, laughing, wanting more.
You had me as you needed, then someone else.  Please ring and say you love me.
Lost you, haven’t I?  Won’t know when it started.  Everyone loves you.  All along you had her.  Five years spent with you friends.  No hold, no trust, over.
Could do with a cigarette, a cup of tea, could eat – let it pass, buy some fruit, can’t buy flowers.  You had her in your bag.  Was there another letter?  I should have checked, found out more.
Happy - being with you, now moved on without me when things were going right.  Everything lost.
Yesterday waiting calm, thought you would admire me, that there was a chance, like new lovers – glamorous, no-one else in your eyes.  I want to be loved, love of your life.  Never forget how it started.

 
SECTION 1
Memories, like fragments scattered along a winding dusty road, gathered and pieced together as a montage of snapshots.  Forever to flounder in the past, disconnected from the present and the future as a dim flickering light.
The room is quiet and still as she toddles towards the door to the kitchen and opening it sees mum, dad and Brendan standing there.
‘Mummy, I’ve pood,’ she says and smiles break across their faces, a stifled laugh.
A photographer coming to the house takes a picture of them poised upon the settee covered in a patterned cloth, alongside Anne the elder and Margaret the younger – her gaze captured in frame of lens wide eyed, innocent.
She lurches towards the fire and her right arm lands upon the scorching black iron grate.
`Holy Frost!’ grandad exclaims jumping to his feet, mad the fireguard wasn’t there and lifting her into his arms runs along the dark chilly road to hospital.  Still she has the scar.
It is a beautiful day at a park, the sun beaming down upon her as she scans the vast expanse of grass.  Seeing only strangers a surge of panic rises and an inner scream battling for release is held down, choked in silence.
Put outside in the garden for some fresh air and peering towards the garage she imagines the bogie man lurking, about to slither down the side and get her.  Screaming up at the kitchen window mum’s face appears smiling.
Summers seem endless, drifting upon a tide of contentment through the long sultry days.
One morning as she trails behind Anne along the garden path she turns to see Margaret skipping up behind them; now one of us.  Mary is inside, sitting on mum’s lap who points at things around the room and names them: light; door; window.  Each word uttered in a clear firm voice and pressed upon as a piece of a jigsaw puzzle slotted into place.
They sing in the garden, at the top end on the grass:
Edelweiss, Every morning you greet me, small and white, clean and bright, you look happy to meet me; The Clapping Song, My mummy told me, if I was goody, then she would buy me a rubber dolly; Que Sera, Sera, When I was just a little girl I asked my mother what will I be, will I be pretty, will I be rich, here's what she said to me ...whatever will be, will be, the future’s not ours to see, que sera sera; Tinker, Tailor, Daisy, Daisy, who shall it be? Who shall it be who will marry me? Rich man, poor man, beggar man, thief.
And, amidst the dreamy warm haze of a blue and cloudless sky the chorus rises to gladden the hearts of angels.
Playing out the back, a dirt track running behind the houses of their road and the grove, a place of escape and adventure:  hide and seek, ‘Count to one hundred in fives – don’t look!’ she exclaims before scurrying behind trees and cars and ducking down low hardly daring to breath; as soldiers crouching in a circle to scratch a plan onto the hard gritty soil with a twig, and swinging on a black oily tyre hanging from a high up thick branch of the mammoth oak tree with deep crevices on its gnarled trunk like the face of a cranky old witch, its bark covered with green sludgy moss and bulbous bare roots pushing through the ground.
‘Quick, get your costumes on!’ she says on a hot sunny afternoon when Patsy and Marie (Kelly) come round and waits impatiently for their return.  Giving someone the end of the hosepipe she sprints across the grass shrieking as cold spurts of water hit upon her warmed skin sending shivers.
Hearing the blast from the ice-cream van in the grove her stomach jolts.  Racing in mum gets some change from the windowsill and they dash into the hall to huddle by the front door waiting to hear the cheery tune in their road.
‘Only one to go,’ mum says cautiously opening the door, `and mind the road!’
Answering the door she sees the ice-cream man, a lodger, carrying a tray of cornets topped with chocolate flakes.  Leading him through to the front room mum gets up from a chair.
‘Ooh, what a surprise!’ she exclaims.
The bread man comes with a large wicker basket over his arm and peering to a glorious display of caramel wafers, club biscuits and cupcakes with lemon icing; the milkman with a crate of silver top bottles and bag of potatoes; the coalman lugging bulky grey sacks through the back door of kitchen and into garden to dump in bunker.
A black splinter trapped under a red raw layer of skin as mum, sitting on a chair in the garden, prises it out with a needle.
With a flurry of activity she makes mud pies filling saucepans from the kitchen tap and snatching forks and spoons.  As she digs into the crusty surface of soil the pungent earthy smell erupts to breeze through her air waves and mixing with saliva swallowed.  With water dribbled upon the dry black mass it becomes sloppy and frothy to be patted into mounds.  A worm wriggling, greyish-pink, translucent; how strange they live after being cut in half. In winter to notice rusty bent tips of forks poking through frost covered ground.
Tying a net curtain, stiff and yellowing, around her head she swirls as a princess with long golden locks flowing.  She imagines one day her prince will come.
`I love you,’ he declares, and holding hands they glide up and away over the hedge.
‘Come in now, it's getting dark!’ mum calls from the back door and she saunters across the grass deflated as a balloon.
`You can have a warm drink before going to bed,’ mum says making sweet tea or cocoa.  And, with Anne creating, she pulls her jumper up and over her head.
They all sleep in one bed:
‘Good night, god bless,’ mum says tucking them in and leaves the door slightly open for light from the landing.  Edging in she makes room for the fairies and then says her prayers thanking god for everything.
‘Stop making a racket.  Go to sleep!’ mum shouts up, annoyed by all the talking and laughing.  And later in a loud high pitched voice, ‘I'll tell your dad and you'll get a good hiding.’ 
Freezing, she asks Anne for a `chair’, she always says yes, and snuggling in to feel some warmth.






Favourite this work Favourite This Author


Comments by other Members



Chestersmummy at 17:03 on 05 December 2016  Report this post
Hi Mia S

Thought I'd kick start of the comments on the beginning of your novel although I'm probably ill-equipped to do so.   Not sure if it works as a novel beginning but really love the images you portray.   As I understand it, your character has just been 'dumped' by her love-term love.   I think you portray her pain, anger and torment perfectly - I am sure most people can identify with how she feels.  The shock of betrayal, the vain hope that he will realise his mistake and return and the misery of realisation that it is not going to happen.  

Then Section 1 - Not quite sure about that but maybe it fits in with the rest of your novel.  I think it is always difficult to critique novels because one never knows what will  transpire.  Anyway, absolutely love your list of memories  and again I can identify with so many of them.  Particularly love your first sentence:
Memories, like fragments scattered along a winding dusty road, gathered and pieced together as a montage of snapshots.

To sum up - I think Section 1 is a catalogue of luscious delights designed to savour at leisure.

My comments probably aren't very helpful but I hope others with more knowledge will chip in.

Best wishes. 

Mia-S at 19:24 on 05 December 2016  Report this post
Hi

Thank you so much for your feedback.  I found your comments very encouraging and helpful.

The opening paragraph is the prologue - kind of to set the scene of what is happening now in the present.  Section 1 goes to the past and the characters earliest memories.  Section 2 comes back to the beginning of the relationship that broke up and so on. 

Like you I struggled with what person, first or third, to write in - so I've used first for the present and third for the past.  I also wasn't sure whether to write in present tense or past, to eventually settle for present. 

I've found it a difficult book to write.  I think this is partly because although it presents memories from the character's childhood I have described them from an adult perspective. 

Regards

Maria


 

Chestersmummy at 19:12 on 06 December 2016  Report this post
Hi Maria

Fully identify with your problems.  My first novel was 'easier' being linear and in the first person.  My second, which I am part-way through is more complicated.  It is writtern from the viewpoint of three characters and goes backwards and forwards in time.   I use the present tense for the present and the past for the past - quite tricky and I find myself relapsing at times

Good luck with yours.  I am sure you will cope better than I will.

BW

Janet

Mia-S at 08:27 on 07 December 2016  Report this post
Hi

Your current novel sounds interesting but challenging, I hope it is going well.

What is your first novel called?  Have you had it published.  I am going to self-publish mine with Lulu.

Maria
 

Chestersmummy at 15:20 on 07 December 2016  Report this post
Hi Maria

No, I have been very lazy.   It got quite a few favourable comments from my previous writing group but I am very technically challenged so didn't go down the self-publishing route although a lot of my colleagues did.  I am going to post it chapter by chapter  so maybe it will get an airing then.  I have called it 'Write me a love story' which maybe gives the wrong impression but I like the title so.....

If you find 'Lulu' 'easy' let me know and I might give it a try.

Janet

judie at 03:52 on 17 December 2016  Report this post
Hi Maria,
I really enjoyed the lyrical quality of your writing, and like Chestersmummy I could identify with virtually all of the memories, making me a certain age I guess - visiting baker? and the milkman, fishmonger, etc.

I'm not sure about the choppiness and stream of consciousness of the first part. I got the emtions, they come through really well. But at times it was just too strange. For example:

Could do with a cigarette, a cup of tea, could eat – let it pass, buy some fruit, can’t buy flowers. 

the last part is a bit too cryptic for me. The opening of this section I find too cryptic as well. I assume it is a nightmare - but it doesn't seem to connect with the rest of the section somehow.

Stunted creature crouched on bed throttling someone to death - broken neck, dark ... coming for me.

Some picky comments.
Does the ice cream van blast - ours used to play Greensleeves or some such tonky tune.

Hearing the blast from the ice-cream van in the grove

Hosepipe sounds like a weapon, maybe it is just hose?

Giving someone the end of the hosepipe she sprints across the grass shrieking as cold spurts of water hit upon her warmed skin sending shivers.

Why does the ice-cream man come into the front room? That sounds a bit odd. And the lodger bit. Also seems odd, maybe nees an explanation, not long just a word or two.

Answering the door she sees the ice-cream man, a lodger, carrying a tray of cornets topped with chocolate flakes.  Leading him through to the front room mum gets up from a chair. ‘Ooh, what a surprise!’ she exclaims.

This one grated on me - if she is deflated would she saunter? And would it be a popped balloon?

Come in now, it's getting dark!’ mum calls from the back door and she saunters across the grass deflated as a balloon.

I think you have used the present tense well. I love the present tense and find it easy to write in. It is kind of appropriate even for writing about past memories.
I am wondering where you will go with this stream of consciousness style. I wouldn't want to read a whole novel in it. It's possibly OK for a prologue but leave it there.
Also what will connect the lost lover relationship with her childhood memories? These memories seem to be the sort you wouldn't bother sharing with a lover, or husband, so what will link them to the story of the adult relationship?
I am really interested in seeing the next section - is it all going to be sections or will there be chapters? I think chapters sounds better for a novel.
Anyway good luck with the evolving story!
Cheers Judie
 

 

 



Mia-S at 08:57 on 17 December 2016  Report this post
Hello Caitlin

Thank you very much for your in depth comments and positivity.

I have decided to move the prologue, first part, to later in the novel where it happens as I think this will make it more understandable.  Instead the book will start with the beginning of that relationship (the present),  followed by the childhood memories (the past).  The structure will continue like this, broken into sections/chapters, of present/past up until the past ends where the present begins.  This may sound confusing, but I'm hoping it works.

I appreciate that my writing style is quite choppy in parts making meaning unclear.  And when editing I'm continually adding words, for clarity, only to take them out again.

Thank you for your `picky' comments ... I will see if I need to look at words/phrases selected.  The icecream man was a lodger in my house, that's why he came into the front room with the icecreams.

There is more stream of consciousness in the present sections following the break up of the relationship.  I have used this for its directness and hope that in context it works.

There isn't a direct connection between the lost lover relationship and childhood memories.  I am presenting the life of a character through her memories.  So, in the aftermath of the breakdown of a relationship, the beginning of that relationship is presented which runs with memories of the character's past, up to the point when the relationship begins.  I hoped that the cut from present to past would be be insightful in drawing upon links between present and past experiences.  The writing isn't really intended to be a story as such but more a slice of life.

I will post the opening section of the novel, the beginning of the relationship, and look forward to your comments.

Regards

Maria 

 

Mia-S at 10:12 on 18 December 2016  Report this post
Hi Judie

Sorry, I've just realised I addressed you as Caitlin, in response to your feedback.

Regards

Maria

Catkin at 19:24 on 20 December 2016  Report this post
Hello Maria,

The opening conveys the narrator’s sense of pain and betrayal very effectively. For me, though, it’s either too experimental - or not experimental enough. I think you should explain things a bit more, and make the language slightly less fragmented, or ramp up the disjointed language and make it even more poetic, so it reads as something closer to a poem than to prose. I say this because I think most readers like to know what’s happening, and don’t like to be confused, but if the language is interesting, complex and poetic enough, then I think you can carry readers with you and they won’t mind the lack of clarity so much, and will appreciate a piece for the language and the mood it creates. So basically, I think you are falling between the two stools of realism and poetry here.

I enjoyed all the childhood memories. It’s saying Sixties or Seventies to me - is that right? Which would make the narrator very roughly fifty-ish now? (Unless the present of the story is also set in the past, of course).

I think the decision to describe the child as ‘she’ - although this is the narrator describing herself - is a good one. It works because it gives a sense of distance, which is appropriate for the at-a-distance quality of the memories. It gives the impression of looking on at one’s own life from the point of view of an outsider. Emotionally, it seems to add a melancholy tinge.

The descriptions of the childhood memories contain a lot of energy and movement, which is excellent - something like this could so easily end up too static.

I’m rather concerned that you say: “There isn't a direct connection between the lost lover relationship and childhood memories” - because readers will definitely be looking for the connections, and if they don’t find them, they’re going to feel cheated. I don’t think the connections have to be huge and obvious in order for it all to work, but I do think they have to be there.

Some nitpicking:
 

‘Mummy, I’ve pood,’

- usually spelled ‘pooed’, but if this is the Sixties/Seventies, I’m not sure people used the word then. I don’t remember it, anyway. The term “poo” has gained a lot of ground in the past 10-15 years. You also use “cupcakes”, and I’m sure no one used that until fairly recently - in the UK, at least. Anything of that sort was called a bun.
 

“them poised upon the settee covered in a patterned cloth”

- makes it sound as if the people are under the cloth.
 

the sun beaming down upon her as she scans the vast expanse of grass.  Seeing only strangers a surge of panic rises

- a beaming sun, a vast expanse and a surge of panic - three cliches close together
 

Each word uttered in a clear firm voice and pressed upon as a piece of a jigsaw puzzle slotted into place

- Lovely! (Would be even better if you changed the ‘as’ to ‘like’)


If you’re going to quote lyrics, make sure they are out of copyright, or that you will be able to afford the fees - music publishers can charge an incredible amount for the right to use even a couple of lines of a lyric.
 

Patsy and Marie (Kelly) come round and waits impatiently for their return.  Giving someone the end of the hosepipe she sprints across the grass shrieking as cold spurts of water hit upon her warmed skin sending shivers.

- why is Kelly in brackets? I think “hit upon” sounds odd, and this sentence seems to stop too soon: shivers where, in what?
 

to dump in bunker

- in the bunker? (Ah, coal bunkers ... the nostalgia. My dad’s still got one in his garden and people don’t know what it is. Every so often, someone asks me what “the concrete box” is for ...)

I think it’s the narrator who puts the cutlery in the mud pies, isn’t it? - but at first I thought it was her mum (because that scene follows hard behind a scene with Mum).

An interesting start with some nice images, and I admire the bravery in the use of language.

Mia-S at 08:52 on 21 December 2016  Report this post
Hi Caitkin

Thank you for your critique - the detail included and effort taken is very much appreciated!

Your comments on the style of writing in the opening as falling between realism and poetry interesting.  I will look over parts of my writing that has this fragmented style.  However, since posting this opening, I have decided to move this opening section of the present to a later section in the book where this experience occurs which I think would make the fragmented words/phrases clearer.

I am happy with your enjoyment of the childhood memories.  Yes, these begin in 1962; these are my memories.  Whilst writing the book I have switched writing the past from first and third person, finally settling for third, and I'm pleased that you think this works.  Quite often I have found continually naming the character `she' problematic as when there are other female characters involved in the same sentence/paragraph the meaning can be confusing.  For example, the last line of this section is I think clumsily written:  Freezing, she asks Anne for a `chair’, she always says yes, and snuggling in to feel some warmth.

For me, it is as if I am an outsider presenting the character's experiences from a distance, because of the distance of time and as the narrator is reflecting upon the experiences/events described.  I've seen this as describing scenes in a film and cutting from one scene (memory) to the next.  I had worried that large chunks of the past might be dull as there is approximately a 4:1 ratio of past/present.

I think there are connections between the past and present in as far as there are links between experiences/events in both generally.  However, I don't think that these connections are necessarily present in each section of present/past as the narrative of is linear as series of chronological events.  I have yet to finalise the structure of the book - it's broken into sections opening with a section of the present followed by the past. 

Thank you for the focussed comments I will look at making some edits.  I said `pood' at this time though I've never seen the word written - maybe it should be `pooed'.  (This was my first ever memory).

I have put `Kelly' in brackets because it's the surname of the friends/neighbours and there is a description of the Kelly's, Mr and Mrs, later.  I'm not how to make this less confusing. 

I have used the word `hit' because it was like being attacked by the spurts of water and also because, with hot skin, the cold water was dreaded.  I have written `sending shivers' because the cold spurts of water caused her to shiver all over, but I will see if I can make this clearer.

Yes, it is he narrator who uses the cutlery to make mud pies; the confusion is caused because of the problem, as mentioned above, of using the `she' of the main character and `she' for other characters close together.  I have avoided using the main character's name, except in dialogue where she is being spoken to.  This is because, as explained above, these are my memoirs and I am looking back at myself as `she'.

I will post the new opening - which begins with the beginning of the relationship and would welcome any feedback on this. Thank you once again.

Best wishes

Maria 

Catkin at 11:02 on 21 December 2016  Report this post
You're welcome. I'm glad it helped.

Why not use the narrator's name? It would make things easier, and I can't see any reason not to. And in cases like this:

"Freezing, she asks Anne for a `chair’, she always says yes" - I think it sounds perfectly natural to repeat a name. It is a repeat, yes; but it's a necessary repeat. I have a theory that necessary repeats don't sound quite a bad as unnecessary repeats, because readers realise that they have to be there. So I'd re-write the sentence above as, Freezing, she asks Anne for a `chair’. Anne always says yes.

Loopygoose at 18:49 on 04 May 2017  Report this post
Hello, this is my first attempt at a critique on this site so I'll be brief while I get some practise at it.  I love the idea of the prologue and the sense of what you are reaching at but I found it a bit too disjointed to engage fully.  You could use the same technique but, perhaps, make the thoughts a little more connected so they're more of stream of consiousness, the way our drifting thoughts do tend to run into each other.  This may be wide of the mark because you may be trying to convey that the person who is having these thoughts has a mental health problem, in which case they will set the tone perfectly and I rather like the idea.  

If that is the case then I'd like to see an even more fluent, lyrical flow in the first chapter to contrast distinctly with what has come before.  Doing that would intrigue the reader and draw them in otherwise you may find the reader is utterly confused and gives up.  

I particularly liked the first line which seems to set the theme for what we are about to read.  
'Memories, like fragments scattered along a winding dusty road, gathered and pieced together as a montage of snapshots.'  
In the first few lines you introduce a number of names but none of them are the name of the person we are supposed to focus or, or any real description of her.  I find that really confusing.  I really want a clearer picture of her, either someone using her name or mentioning something about the way she looks so I can capture her perfectly in my mind's eye.  I'd also like a clearer idea of who is narrating otherwise I'm having to work too hard to understand.  

You have some superbly vivid passages.  I particularly engaged with these - although the first of these sentences is overly long.
‘Count to one hundred in fives – don’t look!’ she exclaims before scurrying behind trees and cars and ducking down low hardly daring to breath; as soldiers crouching in a circle to scratch a plan onto the hard gritty soil with a twig, and swinging on a black oily tyre hanging from a high up thick branch of the mammoth oak tree with deep crevices on its gnarled trunk like the face of a cranky old witch, its bark covered with green sludgy moss and bulbous bare roots pushing through the ground.
‘Quick, get your costumes on!’ she says on a hot sunny afternoon when Patsy and Marie (Kelly) come round and waits impatiently for their return.  Giving someone the end of the hosepipe she sprints across the grass shrieking as cold spurts of water hit upon her warmed skin sending shivers.

I found myself wanting to dwell on these moments and see them expanded rather than move on to more snippets of memory.  
Overall I can see you have some strong material here but I would slow it down and make the strong elements really resonate.  If it's clearer in terms of who we're looking at and who we're listening to then I'd be inclined to read on.  

Mia-S at 12:23 on 05 May 2017  Report this post
Hi Loopygoose

Thank you very much for your critique.  I have found it difficult to sustain the depth or quality of images throughout the novel.  And also as the book is really a succession of snippets of memories it's been difficult to connect these and sustain a flow.  I don't know if many readers will find this structure interesting.  The prologue is in the present and continues in larger sections throughout the book alternating with the past from the earliest childhood memory.  I hoped this would help engage the reader who will see the adult and child justaposed and possibly draw links between past and present experiences.

Maria


To post comments you need to become a member. If you are already a member, please log in .