Login   Sign Up 



 

The Sycamore Tree

by Dan 

Posted: 05 May 2004
Word Count: 202


Font Size
 


Printable Version
Print Double spaced




THE SYCAMORE TREE

The sky blacked out. It began to rain, but he didn’t move. Bigger droplets and more of them fell ever faster. So, it rained harder upon him as he stood in front of his father’s grave. The stone darkened in seconds, even quicker than his clothes. The big sycamore beckoned him. It beckoned him and it offered him many minutes of shelter beneath thick green leaves. He briefly considered this offer. It was a kind offer with no strings attached, but he graciously declined. Partly, he declined because he was soaked by the rain, but mostly he declined because he wanted to remember his father, and he required continuity of thought to achieve this. His father had died twenty-nine years ago. He was now thirty-eight. He was beginning to forget what his father had looked like; this saddened him deeply, but it was an inevitable fact of life, memory, and ageing. For the rest of his life, memories of his father continued to blur, despite this visit. On his deathbed though, he remembered his father with a vivid and wonderful clarity, and he took this memory into the next life, assuming there was such a thing.

©Dan McNeil 2004.






Favourite this work Favourite This Author


Comments by other Members



Anj at 17:13 on 05 May 2004  Report this post
Dan,

I really liked this - I liked your style, tight and graceful at the same time. I liked the way it took us through "his" whole life.

Occasionally though, some lines seemed a bit curt. "The sky blacked out" is good, but too short, seems to need more.

Loved "Bigger droplets and more of them fell ever faster." (that's what I mean by tight and graceful). But maybe it needs commas after droplets and them?

"So, it rained harder upon him" sounded as if "in summary ..."

Loved "the stone darkened"; also "It was a kind offer with no strings attached, but he graciously declined".

"The big sycamore beckoned him. It beckoned him ..." would, for me, have more flow if combined.

"Partly, he declined because he was soaked by the rain" - should this read "he was already soaked ..."?

"His father had died twenty-nine years ago. He was now thirty-eight." I had to stop and work this out, which interrupted the flow - I'd have found it easier if you'd told us the man was 9 when his father died.

From "he was beginning" to the end had some great stuff in it, but seemed somehow as if it needed tightening up.

"and he took this memory into the next life, assuming there was such a thing" confused me a little - if he took the memory into the next life, there must have been such a thing. Also sudden change of POV from his to yours.

Think you need to make, also, more of the tree, which you managed to make seem alive.

Am I being too picky/detailed? Sorry, trying to be helpful. I guess because it's flash, every word counts. But I really liked this piece, found it a moving image, a man alone in the rain by his father's grave, the tree. You made the man and the tree very vivid to me.

Take care
Andrea

Dee at 17:47 on 05 May 2004  Report this post
Dan, this is a lovely little cameo. A whole life in so few words.

Some picky-points:

The big sycamore beckoned him. It beckoned him Here’s a dilemma for you. Anj thinks you should change this. I think it’s one of the most poignant lines in the story. One occasion where repetition comes into its own.

His father had died twenty-nine years ago. He was now thirty-eight. Yes, I agree with Anj here. This stopped me too. It reads as if the second sentence is referring to his father. ou could just switch them round.

He was beginning to forget what his father had looked like; this saddened him deeply, I think, in a tight little piece like this, you should replace the semi-colon with a full stop.

This is a wonderful illustration of a father’s influence on his child. And the fact that time means little when you are missing someone.

Very well written. Is this another example of your ‘writings-under-duress’?

Dee
:)


<Added>

ou could just switch them round. ? ou? What am I on?
You... You could switch...

;)



Dan at 19:48 on 05 May 2004  Report this post
Hi Dee, Anj.

Thanks for feedback. Agree with some of your points, partic. the father/son age. I'll be revising soon.

I actually like the way the sycamore beckoned, think it works well, my favourite piece by a small margin. Just goes to show - writing is weird!

Dee, yes, this one was written under duress as well;).

Thanks both for taking the time to read and post.

Dan.

Anj at 20:21 on 05 May 2004  Report this post
Dee, Dan

Wonder if I made myself clear - I wasn't talking about losing the sycamore beckoning, just combining the two sentences to read "The sycamore beckoned him and it offered ..."? Perhaps I did, perhaps I didn't.

Take care
Andrea

<Added>

Dee, re-reading your comment, you obviously did understand my point. I bow my head.

Dee at 20:35 on 05 May 2004  Report this post
Aw, shucks Andrea... x

crowspark at 16:30 on 06 May 2004  Report this post
Hi Dan
Really liked this.
There is a nice development up to "The stone darkened in seconds" which I particularly liked.
Bill

ShayBoston at 08:19 on 11 May 2004  Report this post
Hi Dan,

You've received good crit on this from Dee and Anj, so i just wanted to say I thought it was well written with a poignant ending.

Regards,

Shay



To post comments you need to become a member. If you are already a member, please log in .